Posts Tagged ‘Derek Boogaard’
Earlier today, Mike Russo of the Star-Tribune posted what will be the Wild’s depth chart if it starts the season with the way the roster is now:
Kim Johnsson-Brent Burns
Nick Schultz-Marek Zidlicky
Greg Zanon-Shane Hnidy
John Scott-Jaime Sifers
Tyler Cuma-Justin Falk
Clayton Stoner-Jamie Fraser
Marco Scandella-Maxim Noreau
Andrew Brunette-Mikko Koivu-Martin Havlat
Owen Nolan-James Sheppard-Pierre-Marc Bouchard (RW until training camp)
Antti Miettinen-Eric Belanger-Cal Clutterbuck
Colton Gillies-Kyle Brodziak-Derek Boogaard
Petr Kalus-Benoit Pouliot-Craig Weller
Robbie Earl-Morten Madsen-Danny Irmen
Matt Kassian-Cody Almond-Carson McMillan
First of all, if you haven’t checked out Mike Russo’s blog and you’re a Wild fan, shame on you. It’s one of the best resources for all things Wild out there. Click here to go there. Bookmark it, scour it daily and above all thank him for his amazing coverage of the Wild!
Anyway, off my soapbox for the moment.
Looking at this depth chart, the thing that immediately jumps out at me is not the center position. A lot has been made of our depth (or lack thereof) down the middle. In looking at the team, however, we’ve got five potential pivots on our roster, and that’s not including Colton Gillies, Owen Nolan or Benoit Pouliot. Throw those two into the mix and we could have as many as eight players on the opening day that could be capable of anchoring a line in the middle.
The thing that really jumps out at me is our lack of depth at left wing. After Nolan, Andrew Brunette and Antti Miettinen, the talent level really drops off. This isn’t a knock on Gillies; however, we have a serious lack of skill and depth on the left side and, honestly, on the wing in general.
To no one’s surprise, I’m sure, is our talent on defense and in nets. Our top-six defensemen could be the best top-six that the team has had. The additions of Zanon and Hnidy give the team two reliable, physical anchors on the blueline and will force opposing teams to keep their heads up. Meanwhile, expect Scott and Sifers to compete for the seventh spot in camp, most likely with Scott winning the battle. That’s not to say, however, that our youth could not come in and surprise. With Cuma, Falk, Stoner and Scandella in the wings, there is a good chance that Scott and Sifers may not be foregone conclusions at the 7 and 8 slot. It will take a lot for any of these four to make the squad, however. Of the four, Stoner probably has the best shot as this could be his make it or break it year, but make no mistake — the Wild’s top 7 are pretty much set.
Olvecky Signs in Nashville
Joel Ward, Ryan Jones and now Olvecky? Those Tennessee boys sure do like Wild prospects.
In all honesty, I think that Olvecky has a fantastic chance to make the Nashville squad next season right out of camp. Olvecky is a big body with a lot of untapped talent to boot, and he performed admirably for the Wild in a limited role with the team in the handful of games he played for us last season.
He really started to come into his own last season and seems like he could be the type of player that Barry Trotz will really love. For $600K and a two-way contract, I’d take Olvecky any day of the week. A good depth pick up by the Preds.
Qualifying Offers Signed
The Wild had a few players of their own signed as well.
Restricted free agents Benoit Pouliot, Clayton Stoner, Danny Irmen and Robbie Earl all signed their qualifying offers and it seems as if the lot of them (with the exception of Pouliot) could see another year playing in the minors. Earl and Irmen both have too many players in front of them to have a shot at making the squad (that is, barring a spectacular camp from either) and Stoner will have to do some serious damage in camp to work his way up the depth chart.
Injuries do happen, though, and we could very easily see one of them get a cup of coffee in the NHL and do what Cal Clutterbuck did last season and not let go.
In addition, Russo reports that the Wild could be close to signing Duncan Milroy and Joe DiSalvatore to plug some holes in their minor league system.
Fletcher Working Trade Market
There are a lot of people who are getting scared by the Wild’s seeming lack of movement this off season.
Those fans are the Chicken Littles of the fanbase.
While there are some quality players out there, there really aren’t any players that would meet any immediate needs for us. I mentioned Mats Sundin, Robert Lang and Mike Comrie previously, but Sundin likely doesn’t have much more tread on his tires, Lang is rumored (or already has) to jump ship to the KHL and Comrie, well, let’s just say I don’t want to sign a player for his girlfriend. In addition to those players, there are players such as Alex Tanguay and Petr Sykora left over. Undoubtedly, these players could make an impact on the Wild roster, but would they really fit?
In the case of Tanguay, he’s a tremendous talent, but he’s also been pigeonholed as a playmaker — of which, the Wild have many. Sykora would be a cheap, effective sniper, but do the Wild want to sink the money it would take to get him on an aging player?
Bottom line is that the best route for the team to improve, at this point, is the route that Fletcher is taking — trades.
There are many top flight forwards that have been presumed available via trade. Phil Kessel of the Boston Bruins, Dany Heatley of the Ottawa Senators, Jonathan Cheechoo of the San Jose Sharks, even Chicago’s Patrick Sharp, Dustin Byfuglien and Patrick Kane have always been rumored to be available.
To be honest, the names remaining in free agency don’t even hold a candle to a lot of these names. I’d much rather have a Kessel, Heatley, Sharp or Kane over any of those available — regardless of the assets we have to give up for them.
The bottom line is that the Wild are far from done, in my opinion. But Fletcher has said all along that he’s not afraid to go late into the summer with a less than full roster to give himself the flexibility that he needs to get the players it takes to make this a winning team.
Fear not Chicken Little. The sky is not falling. With a little patience, we could have a playoff team yet.
SI has recently posted a list of the NHL’s “Most Rugged” players and one of Wild Nation’s personal favorite hockey blogs, Puck Daddy, has responded with their revised list, of which Wild winger Owen Nolan was one.
All of this got me thinking. The Wild has never really been the epitome of a “rugged” team, save for the playoffs two years ago when they had the Four Horsemen (Derek Boogaard, Aaron Voros, Todd Fedoruk and Chris Simon) on their roster. But last season, who could have been considered the Wild’s “Most Rugged” players? After some serious thought, here’s what I came up with:
5) Brent Burns – From his gap-toothed smile to his perpetual almost-beard, rugged is certainly a word that is befitting of the Wild’s brightest star on the blueline. Burnsie does it all. He hits, he scores, he plays good defense; and let’s be honest. The man played the last six weeks of his season with a concussion. That’s rugged.
4) Stephane Veilleux – The reisdent red-headed stepchild of the Wild has always been one to mix it up with anyone at any time. He’s played through broken bones on his face on multiple occasions and is always front and center when the Wild’s checking line comes into the discussion. One of the best checking line players the Wild has had, Veilleux will try to cash in on this ruggedness this summer.
3) Cal Clutterbuck – The new face of the Wild’s checking line certainly put on a show this last season. Clutterbuck gained noteriety from his big hits, despite his small stature. Throw in another perpetual chin growth and you’ve got one rugged player. Besides…Anytime you anger Don Cherry to the point where he gives you a derogatory nickname, you must be doing something right.
2) Andrew Brunette – Truth be told, Brunette has never been known for his physical play, but he gets the nod over Clutterbuck here due to the fact that a) he looks like he’s one day of forgetting to shave away from joining Han Solo aboard the Millenium Falcon and b) he played the last three months of this season with a torn ACL. Now that’s rugged.
1) Owen Nolan – We’ve got to give the nod to the Wild’s resident badass on this one. You know a player commands fear and respect when he’s allowed to screen the goalie pretty much unimpeded, which Nolan did all season long. On top of that, he is the only player on the Wild’s team that is allowed to break the gameday dress code because, quite simply, no one wants to tell him that he can’t; not to mention that he penciled himself into the line up this season, coming back early from an injury. As Burns said about him in a session of Hockey Unplugged; you don’t want to mess with him. He could firebomb your car.
- Wild prospect Cody Almond is playing in the Memorial Cup with the Kelowna Rockets. Almond has been signed to an entry level deal and will play with the Aeros next season. Mike Russo of the Minneapolis Star Tribune also pointed out that Almond takes nearly all of the big faceoffs for Kelowna, not to mention has got some great wheels on him and is a solid penalty killer. Almond was second in playoff scoring in the WHL with 27 points in 22 games.
- The search for the next GM of the Wild continues. For what it’s worth, my prediction for this is Pierre McGuire as GM and Pat Quinn as coach. Second interviews should be wrapping up shortly, however, and we may have a new GM as soon as next week.
- The Aeros avoided elminiation by downing the Manitoba Moose in OT, 5-4. The Aeros now trail 3-1 and will face elimination again in Game 5 in Houston.
Goalie Niklas Backstrom will indeed have left hip surgery Friday in Vail. Brian Stensaas was on a conference call with acting GM Tom Lynn. He reports he has two cysts on the bony part of his hip.
Lynn says they won’t know how long he’ll be out until they operate. Worst case scenario, Stensaas says, could be four to six months!
But Lynn said the doctor cautions they can’t give a timetable yet. More from Stensaas in Wednesday’s paper.
Also, I hear Brent Burns is having shoulder surgery probably on Thursday.
This is in addition to Andrew Brunette having reconstructive knee surgery this off season and Derek Boogaard having shoulder surgery.
So what does this mean for the Wild? Well, if the prognosis for Backstrom truly is 4-6 months, that puts Backstrom back at the earliest, August 24th and at the latest October 24th. Knowing Backstrom, he will work his hardest to rehab and be back sooner, but this essentially makes the top priority for the new GM hammering out a deal for back up goalie Josh Harding.
If this is indeed the case, you can take Harding off of the table as a bargaining chip. That is, unless the new GM is suddenly stricken by Barry Brust-mania and believes that Brust can shoulder the load as an NHL starter. What this could do, however, is drive Harding’s stock through the roof. If Harding can perform like Backstrom did when he wrested the starting job away from Manny Fernandez a few years back, Harding could easily become a hot commodity among NHL teams.
The Search Begins
After being denied permission by Brian Burke and the Toronto Maple Leafs to speak with Dave Nonis, Wild owner Craig Leipold recieved permission from the Nashville Predators to speak with a couple of his old employees; Director of Hockey Operations Mike Santos and assistant GM Paul Fenton.
Leipold declined comment on them, ”just like I won’t comment on any of the other candidates.”
There are lots of candidates that have surfaced. These are just two that so far I know he’ll be allowed to talk with. I’m sure there are others. I’m working the phones.
Santos is in his third year in Nashville and is responsible in negotiating player contracts and preparing for salary arbitrations. He served as assistant GM for the New York Islanders from 1997-2002 and director of hockey operations for the Florida Panthers from 2002-03.
He was Commissioner and President of the North American Hockey League from 2003-06. He’s worked for USA Hockey and the NHL.
Fenton is in his third year as Nashville’s assistant GM after eight as the director of player personnel. He oversees the Predators’ amateur player development and managers the team’s pro and amateur scouting staffs. He’s also GM of the AHL Milwaukee Admirals.
Fenton, who played eight years in the NHL for seven teams and was a former Boston University standout, also spent five seasons working for the Anaheim Ducks.
It hasn’t happened yet, but another person I’d assume Leipold would request permission to speak with his Pittsburgh assistant GM Chuck Fletcher. He’s 41 with 16 years of experience. He’s immensely respected after years in Florida, Anaheim and Pittsburgh.
Remember, Leipold has a fabulous relationship with Penguins GM Ray Shero, who used to be assistant GM in Nashville.
In addition, the Wild have been denied permission to speak with Red Wings assistant GM Jim Nill. Nill is under contract until 2010-11 and has a commitment in his contract to stay in Detroit. In fact, this quote was run in the Windsor Star when Toronto was inquiring about Nill’s availability.
The way we do things here, I’ve already got most of the responsibilities and input that a general manager would have. Ken [Holland] and I work really well together.
I’m comfortable, I’m well-compensated and I like the organization. I know which side my bread is buttered on.
You’ve got to love hockey guys. Doug Risebrough held his “exit presser” yesterday and held it at Tom Reid’s Hockey City Pub. Gotta love it.
Anyway, Russo had some snippets in his blog regarding the players and it just shows how well respected Risebrough was by his own players. Derek Boogaard had his fiancee drive to the pub after he literally just woke up from having shoulder surgery, just so that he could thank Risebrough for the opportunity and have a chance to say goodbye. Risebrough also spent some quality time with Marian Gaborik at the arena and went to Brent Burns’ home to meet with the youngster after the new broke regarding his concussion problems.
Again, on a personal level, I’m sad to see Risebrough go. He was a great guy, probably the nicest associated with the NHL that I’ve had the pleasure to meet. Part of me feels that he deserved a bit better treatment than he received from Leipold; however, that’s also Leipold’s perogative as the owner. It’s his team and he can run it as he sees fit.
On a business level, however, it was time for a change. Risebrough had become increasingly defensive about his decisions over the past few seasons and it seemed as if fans, management and players alike were all growing tired of his smug, “I know best” attitude. As disappointed as I am that it had to end like this, it certainly had to end.
In the transcript of the presser, however, there was one quote from Risebrough that really rings true to me.
I think the club, I believe the club is in really good shape, and I’ll tell you why. I think it’s got a good core of players. It’s got good youth. I think it’s got great flexibility in terms of the salary cap. It’s got lots of room this year, it’s got lots of room next year. So whether that means what do you want to do immediate signings or future signings, it’s all there. It’s got a great fan base that’s still in love with this team. So it’s going to be energized. I believe players that had poor years will rebound. I’m pretty comfortable to say the injuries aren’t going to be the same magnitude. So I think it’s a great opportunity for a manager and I think it’s a great opportunity for a coach. And I feel good about that. I made decisions on a regular basis for the right reasons, and the right reasons never included me. They never included me, they were always for the franchise. Now I can say, I didn’t always make the right decisions, but I did them for the right reasons. And I feel good about that.
That right there, to me, says it all. Whoever it is has a good base, but also has his work cut out for him. This is a solid team in need of a few key components to become a serious contender. I don’t think this team needs to be blown up and start from scratch again, but at the same time I don’t think that this team is ready to contend next season after all of this going on this off season. One thing’s for sure, though. It’s still an exciting time to be a Wild fan!
The season has ended and Jacques Lemaire has stepped down as the coach of the Minnesota Wild. A big weekend in Minnesota hockey, to be sure. So today, true to my word, I will begin my season review of the team; first, starting with the forwards.
Mikko Koivu – 9 – C | 79 GP, 20 – 47 – 67, +2:In a word, Koivu’s season was okay. Most likely, more was expected of him both by himself and by the fans, however he showed marked improvement over his last couple seasons and looks as if he will continue to improve towards next season. He certainly showed flashes of brilliance; however, he was mired by inconsistency late in the season, at one point going eight games without even registering a point in what could have been considered the period of the season where the Wild needed him most. In all, Koivu had a good season, but was not what was needed by the team. Grade: B
Andrew Brunette – 15 – L | 80 GP, 22 – 28 – 50, -5: Let’s be fair. Bruno was exactly what Wild fans expected. He did everything that the team expected from him and was a true leader on and off the ice. I don’t think that anyone expected him to be a 80 point scorer, but he was expected to be steady and he was exactly that. He munches minutes, he controls the puck and he’s solid in his own zone. I’m sure he would have liked to be more consistent, as there were multiple long stretches where he failed to register a point, but overall he was one of the top players on the team. Grade: A-
Pierre-Marc Bouchard – 96 – C | 71 GP, 16 – 30 – 46, -5:Fresh off of a new contract, Bouchard struggled for the first half of the season. He struggled to find his groove in the offensive zone and was tentative for a lot of the season. Once he hit his stride, however, he was as good as any player in the league. After the All Star break, Bouchard turned it on and was one of the top players on the team. As with Bruno and Koivu, however, finding any sort of consistency was a struggle for Bouchard and his season could have been much better than it was with some sort of consistency. Grade: B-
Owen Nolan – 11 – R | 59 GP, 25 – 20 – 45, +5:I was as thrilled as anybody that the Wild had signed “Cowboy” during the off season. Nolan has always been one of my favorite players and to see him come to the Wild was something that I absolutely loved. While injuries slowed his season, Nolan was one of the big reasons why the loss of Marian Gaborik for the majority of the season was not an unmitigated disaster for the Wild. He came on with a punch that I don’t think anyone expected from him and immediately became a fan favorite. Despite playing injured for most of the season, Nolan was one of the Wild’s best players and the only thing that holds his final evaluation back is the fact that he was injured for a good chunk of the year. Grade: B+
Antti Miettinen – 20 – R | 82 GP, 15 – 29 – 44, -1:I think if you asked any Wild fan what they expected from Antti Miettinen, they would have said something like the old Antti that the Wild had (of the Laaksonen variety). I don’t, however, think that they would have responded by saying that the young Finn would be a 40+ point scorer. “Mittens,” as he has so lovingly been dubbed by Wild fans, came out like gangbusters and, eventually, cooled off later in the season but his impact on the Wild’s roster was immediate. He brought a hard-working, defensively sound presence to the team that complemented the line up that they had perfectly. He meshed well with countryman Mikko Koivu, but also fit into other roles quite easily. His performance was a pleasant surprise on a team that did not have many this season. Grade: A-
Eric Belanger – 25 – C | 79GP, 13 – 23 – 36, -5: One thing can be said of Belanger. He is certainly consistent. What is frustrating about him, however, is that you occasionally see flashes of brilliance that make it maddening to watch him at times. There were times this season where Belanger was a magician in the offensive zone and there were times where he was brilliant in the defensive zone. Belanger is a checking line center that was thrust into a second line center role this season and performed admirably. He plays with a passion for the game that is hard to miss. The trouble is that the team didn’t need him to produce like a checking line center this season. They needed him to step up his game and produce like a second line center; and this, he did not do. Grade: C
James Sheppard – 51 – C | 82 GP, 5 – 19 – 24, -14: By all accounts, James Sheppard was a massive disappointment this season. His performance towards the end of last season had Wild fans and management alike optimistic that he might step into the limelight and take over a larger role on the team. Sheppard failed to step up to the task and was such a disappointment that he even began to see regular shifts with the fourth line or be benched in important moments. The only thing that salvaged his season was, again, a late season push in which the youngster began to show his true potential, notching 1 goal and 7 assists for 8 points in eleven games and a +6 over this time. Grade: D
Marian Gaborik – 10 – R | 17 GP, 13 – 10 – 23, +3:In what will likely be Gaborik’s last season with the team, fans are left wondering what could have been. In just 17 games, Gaborik proved his worth to the team by lighting a fire under himself. Not only did he lead the team to a 7-3-1 record down the stretch, but also gave Wild fans one of the most electrifying 11-game stretches in recent memory. This stretch saved Gaborik’s season from being a bitter disappointment; however, 65 games missed cannot be ignored. Grade: D+
Stephane Veilleux – 19 – L | 81GP, 13 – 10 – 23, -17:Again, in what will likely be Veilleux’s last season with the Wild, the scrappy winger put together a fairly solid campaign. After his outburst at the end of last season, however, the team was certainly expecting more from him and he simply didn’t deliver on this early in the season. As he approaches free agency, he may have to reevaluate his standing with the team as he will likely not be back. Grade: C-
Cal Clutterbuck – 22 – R | 78 GP, 11 – 7 – 18, -5: Cal Clutterbuck came to Minnesota, leaving his car parked in the airport parking lot; thinking that he would be back in a few days. A couple months later, he was told to find a place to live. That pretty much sums up the rookie’s first full NHL season that made him a cult hero in Minnesota and even incited a grassroots Calder Trophy campaign. In his rookie season, he broke the NHL hits record and showed some offensive flair as well, leaving Wild fans hopeful for the years to come. Grade: A+
Dan Fritsche – 49 – L | 50 GP, 5 – 8 – 13, -5: Fritsche was a press box mainstay in New York, but quickly became a checking and fourth line mainstay for the Wild. With many fans disappointed that the Wild simply did not claim him off waivers, Fritsche quietly came out and made an impact for the Wild and endeared himself to the fans. A hard worker and a solid player, Fritsche will be looked towards to play a larger role on the team if he stays in Minnesota. Grade: C+
Benoit Pouliot – 67 – L | 37 GP, 5 – 6 – 11, +1: Pouliot was another of the Wild’s young disappointments this season. Expected to come in and help complement Marian Gaborik, Pouliot came out and showed flashes of brilliance during his stay with the Wild. Unfortunately, these flashes of brilliance were punctuated by stretches of apathy by the youngster. If he remains with the team, he will likely be on his last shot to make the big show. Grade: F
Peter Olvecky – 28 – L | 31 GP, 2 – 5 – 7, +1: The young Slovak may have played his way into a short one-way contract for next season with the way that he played in his limited call up. Solid two-way play and some solid offensive zone play even led to the youngster getting time on special teams as the season wore down. If he stays in Minnesota, next season he will be looked at to show some more of his offensive talent. Grade: C
Colton Gillies – 18 – L | 45 GP, 2 – 5 – 7, -2:This season was to be a learning season for young Colton, and learn he did. A relentlessly hard worker, Gillies was among the last off every practice, even when he was playing and soaked up all he could from the Wild’s extremely experienced coaching staff. Gillies wasn’t expected to do much this season, but next will be where the rubber meets the road. Grade: C
Krystofer Kolanos – 39 – C | 21 GP, 3 – 3 – 6, +3: Kolanos showed flashes of why he was a first round pick this season, but was ultimately deemed to inconsistent to remain with the team. Should he be re-signed, he will likely need to show more consistent offensive production to stick with the team. Grade: C-
Derek Boogaard – 24 – L | 51 GP, 0 – 3 – 3, +3: Much to the surprise of many, Boogaardcame out this season and actually tried to play hockey. In fact, the big man didn’t even break 100 PIMs or just the second time in his career. Hampered by injuries again, this fan favorite didn’t stand out in any way; surprisingly, not even fighting. Grade: C
Craig Weller – 12 – R | 36 GP, 1 – 2 – 3, -3:Weller was slated to be “Boogaard Lite” for this team; however, he was unable to stick with the team for any extended period of time. Often scratched, Weller simply did not impress enough to earn consistent ice time and was regularly a mainstay on the bench next to the back up goaltender when he was dressed. Grade: F
So there you have it. The season review for the forwards.
Up Next: Defense and Goaltending
Also, keep it tuned here tonight for the premiere of Wild Nation, Hockey Primetime’s official Minnesota Wild radio show!
Let me clarify one thing right off the bat. This will not be a long diatribe condemning fighting, nor will this be a thesis on how the NHL should let players police themselves. Like Fox News, I will attempt to be “fair and balanced” in my views (and likely have much greater success at doing so).
I’m not going to mince words. I enjoy fighting in the NHL. I certainly do think it has a place and I most definitely do not think that it is a distraction from the game; at least not all of the time. In the right context, fights can change the momentum of a game or limit the effectiveness of a player. At the same time, however, I appreciate the fact that the Board of Governors is attempting to get a handle on fighting in the NHL.
Let’s face it. As entertaining as the occasional “enforcer” fight may be, it adds little to nothing to the game itself. I would imagine that seven or eight times out of ten, these fights between heavyweights involve the two bruisers lining up next to each other on the face off, chirping at one another, then dropping the gloves in an attempt to make their paltry five minutes or less of ice time memorable. The simple fact is that the role of enforcer on an NHL team is as antiquated as players not wearing helmets.
What exactly do these enforcers bring to the game? It’s certainly not protection, as there are now many players on teams that are not considered to be enforcers but drop the gloves when need be. On most teams, the enforcers are relegated to a few minutes of ice time that will likely be eclipsed by their penalty minutes in that game.
Derek Boogaard (F Min) – 50 GP, 0 G, 3 A, 87 PIM, 5:03 TOI
Donald Brashear (F Was) – 63 GP, 1 G, 3 A, 121 PIM, 8:14 TOI
Wade Belak (F Nas) – 53 GP, 0 G, 2 A, 79 PIM, 5:15 TOI
Georges Laraque (F Mon) – 28 GP, 0 G, 2 A, 52 PIM, 7:35 TOI
Eric Godard (F Pit) – 65 GP, 2 G, 1 A, 159 PIM, 4:02 TOI
David Koci (F TB) – 27 GP, 0 G, 1 A, 99 PIM, 5:31 TOI
There you have it. Six of the more “notorious” fighters in the game today. Not one topping ten minutes in ice time and not one topping more than four points. Can you honestly tell me that these players have an impact on their team or on the game? Yes, there are certainly players that can have an impact on the game in eight minutes of ice time. Those players are also the ones that are atop the leaders in points or even in hits or even in plus/minus rating. But the honest truth is that the majority of enforcers in the NHL are nothing more than liabilities on the ice.
But fighting does have a place in the NHL. Looking at the new rule changes that the Board of Governors are thinking about instituting, I whole-heartedly agree with the decision to give anything that could be construed as a “staged fight” a 10-minute game misconduct. What I do not agree with, however, is the NHL’s decision to attempt to negate fights after a big, clean hit.
Think about it. Hockey is an emotional game and the majority of fights in hockey are spurred on by emotion. Some of the most memorable are as well. But what the NHL is trying to do here is nothing more than a token attempt to “clean up” fighting, and a poor one at that. If a player gets caught by a big, clean hit, he should certainly have to answer for it. Now I’m not talking about those big hits where the player gets knocked over the boards or gets plowed behind the net or anything where the player gets hit and pops back up. I’m talking the Brandon Sutter type hits, where the players gets run through cleanly and, consequently, is not able to get back up immediately and return the favor.
There are players on all teams whose job description, quite frankly, is to check. Some have talent past that, some are solely used for checking purposes. Just like fighting, hitting is part of the game. The problem I have with the NHL’s proposed rule change is that the team has no recourse in these situations. The opposing player does not have to pay any price for running around, hitting anything that moves. Clean or not, it is a dangerous precedent to allow players to run around, hitting anything and everything and not have to answer for doing so.
Look at the fights that are spurred on by emotion. Jarome Iginla vs. Vincent Lecavalier? The Buffalo Sabres vs. the Ottawa Senators? Brent Burns vs. Chris Kunitz? Emotion can make a fight, just as lack of emotion can break it…Just as with hockey. Animosity in a fight can lead to an absolutely brilliant brawl; not two heavyweights who can barely skate holding each other up for 30 seconds.
My thought? Take the staged stuff out of the game. Force those players to evolve or be forced out of the NHL. Let emotion rule the fights; not two players just trying to get their minute in the spotlight for the game.